Whether you like perfectly drawn eyebrows or thick, natural-looking ones, eyebrow pencils are a must-have. They help accentuate the shape of your natural brows, make them fuller, and enhance the symmetry of your face. While it is ideal to buy an eyebrow pencil that matches your hair colour, you also need to consider its stay, texture, tip type, and pigmentation. Since eyebrow pencils are huge in the makeup industry, it’s not a surprise that there are dozens of options.
Our Top Recommendations
How Do We Choose the Best Eyebrow Pencils?
Eyebrows are an essential facial feature that plays a major role in eye makeup. Grooming them well and filling them in can help you feel empowered and confident. And to create full, thick brows, you need to have the right tool in your brow kit – The Eyebrow Pencil. Brow pencils are a great tool that can transform the most uneven brows into perfectly defined arches. They can be used to shape, define, and sculpt your brows without creating a lot of mess. Also, they are available for all budgets, ranging from Rs 50 to Rs 2000. To spare you the hassle of experimenting with a hundred different ones, here is a list of our top favourite eyebrow pencils to help you rock that flawless brow.
Here are some of the factors you must consider to choose the right eyebrow pencil.
The right colour of eyebrow pencil can make a huge difference. You need to choose a brow pencil a shade lighter than your hair. Choosing the colour same as the brows is a common mistake that people make. Eyebrow pencils have a thicker formula and deposit more colour. Using the same shade or darker will make the eyebrows look chalky and painted on. So, always pick a shade lighter that can blend easily and give a natural yet enhanced look.
Most brow pencils have a brow brush on one end. Having this feature makes the entire process of drawing or filling in the brows easier. The brush or spoolie aids in spreading the pencil deposit evenly throughout the brow length. Also, the eyebrow pencil with a sharper makes for a great purchase. It helps maintain the sharpness and condition of the pencil. So, while buying a pencil, make sure it comes with these add-on features or get an eyebrow gel to get more defined eyebrows.
List of Top 12 Eyebrow Pencils for That Perfect Arch
Wet n Wild Ultimate Brow Pencil
If you are someone who likes natural-looking brows, this retractable eyebrow pencil from Wet n Wild is the perfect one for you. It creates fine hair-like strokes with its unique triangular tip and gives a smooth finish even at the edges. Available in three natural shades, it has a rub-resistant pigment that enhances your brows and keeps them lifted throughout the day. This brow pencil has an in-built spoolie that helps brush your eyebrows and blend the pigment for a more defined look.
Prominent Features of the Wet n Wild Ultimate Brow Pencil:
- Easy to hold
- Super pigmented and creamy
- In-built spoolie
- Triangular tip
- Perfect for beginners
- Limited colour options
Why We Picked the Wet n Wild Ultimate Brow Pencil?
Wet n Wild Ultimate Brow Pencil comes in light colours that go well with all Indian skin tones. It is a versatile brow pencil that defines and fills the gap precisely. It just takes a few strokes of this pencil to enjoy a visible difference. Also, it is easy to use, shut, and store. Apart from the pencil, the spoolie is an awesome feature. It is smooth and blends everything perfectly. Without a doubt, it is the right tool to instantly awaken your eyes.
Blue Heaven Brow Definer Stick
The Blue Heaven eyebrow definer roll-on stick has a 12-hour long stay and a smudge-proof formula that comes with a broad slanted tip for precise application. Enriched with organic vegetable oils that nourish and moisturise your brows, the stick comes in two natural colours- brown and grey. Ideal for quick application, this product is water-resistant, so you look flawless throughout the day. The broad tip ensures that the product gets evenly distributed, and the angled tip adds definition, so your eyebrows look naturally fuller.
Prominent Features of the Blue Heaven Brow Definer Stick:
- Waterproof formula
- Highly affordable
- It comes in 2 natural colours
- Gives fuller eyebrows
- It cannot be sharpened
Why We Picked the Blue Heaven Brow Definer Stick?
Blue Heaven Brow Definer Stick gives professional results at a much lesser price than other options. It is a brow-styling, roll-on pencil that ensures smooth and easy application. This pencil is loaded with special ingredients that give a beautiful finish and make the eyebrows healthy. It is a perfect blend of pigment and moisturiser that helps in achieving the precise shape of the eyebrow. Plus, it is compact and travel-friendly, which makes it a great buy.
Sugar Cosmetics Brow Definer
Whether you like naturally bushy eyebrows or thin, arched ones, the Sugar Cosmetics Arch Arrival Brow Definer will do it for you. The pointed tip can be used to draw precise outlines, and the spoolie can be used to blend in the pigment for a better finish. This pencil is perfect for women who wear makeup for long hours since it is waterproof and gives 12-hour coverage for long wear. Available in four shades to suit all Indian skin tones, it is a lightweight, travel-friendly option for all women.
Prominent Features of the Sugar Cosmetics Brow Definer:
- Very handy and travel-friendly
- Spill-proof spoolie
- Lasts for 12 hours
- Triangular slant tip
- Matte finish
- The tip might break under too much pressure
Why We Picked the Sugar Cosmetics Brow Definer?
Sugar is a well-known brand offering cruelty-free products. The Brow Definer is one of them. It is a sweat and humidity-resistant pencil that works wonders for filling empty spaces and bald spots in the brows quickly. Its easy application makes it perfect for daily use. The pencil is decently pigmented and stays intact even after long working hours. It does not slide around and does not even require regular touch-ups throughout the day.
Furthermore, if you are searching for glitter eye shadow, then do check out our list of the best glitter eye shadow brands in India. Do check it out.
Faces Canada Eyebrow Pencil
This precision tip Ultimate Pro Eyebrow Defining Pencil from Faces Canada gives a smooth matte finish to your brows. Easy to sharpen, it can be used to outline or fill the eyebrows, while the in-built spoolie comes in handy for combing the brows upwards to get a more lifted look. Perfect for everyday users, it is simple to use and wipes off easily with a makeup remover. If you are searching for a clean brow product for everyday use, this is it.
Prominent Features of the Faces Canada Eyebrow Pencil:
- High colour pay-off
- Soft powdery formula
- Offers 12 hours stay
- Fills sparse eyebrows
- Can be sharpened
- Ideal for daily use
- The sleek tip makes it longer to fill brows
Why We Picked the Faces Canada Eyebrow Pencil?
Faces Canada Eyebrow Pencil is a good-looking, sleek pencil that has a super-fine tip. It easily defines and fills your eyebrows in a single application and looks impeccable all day long. Its natural colours easily replicate the looks of actual eyebrows and give a beautiful finish. Also, it has a built-in, high-quality spoolie that adds a professional touch without doing much. The soft-powder formula does not feel cakey and is smudge-proof, waterproof, and transfer-resistant.
Lakme Eyebrow Pencil
This classic stick eyebrow pencil comes from the house of Lakme. Meant for bold and dramatic eyebrows, it can be sharpened for easy application. The smudge-free formula eliminates the need for constant touch-ups and lasts all day long to give you well-defined eyebrows. Waterproof and highly pigmented, it does not lighten, transfer, or feather even upon extended wear. Found in the vanities of most makeup artists, it is still the top choice for many.
Prominent Features of the Lakme Eyebrow Pencil:
- Easy to sharpen and use
- Thick pigment
- Long-lasting formula
- Adds depth and shape to brows
- Highly affordable
- Requires frequent sharpening
Why We Picked the Lakme Eyebrow Pencil?
Lakme Eyebrow Pencil is a must-have to add definition, shape and volume to the brows. It is a creamy black formula that works the best in creating dramatic, bold looks. This pencil is easy to maintain and comes with enough product that runs for a long time. It is an impressive tool that locks the hair in place. It accentuates the eye makeup and adds to your glam quotient. If you want all the features at an affordable price, you should try this eyebrow pencil.
Miss Claire Eyebrow Pencil
This eyebrow pencil by Miss Claire is the one for you if you like lifted eyebrows with fuller arches. Meant for precise application, this pencil can be used to create short strokes that mimic the hair of your brows for a more natural look. Available in three shades suitable for Indian skin tones, its waterproof formula gives you unbelievable coverage all day long. This eyebrow pencil has a smudge-proof formula that does not melt or lighten and is ideal for women on the go.
Prominent Features of the Miss Claire Eyebrow Pencil:
- It befits all skin tones
- Long-lasting formula
- Comes with brush
- Natural-looking results
- The shades might be too dark for very fair skin tones
Why We Picked the Miss Claire Eyebrow Pencil?
This amazing eyebrow pencil from Miss Claire stays for long without getting smeared. It highlights your brows neatly while giving you natural-looking coverage with fuller arches. The pencil is perfect for covering sparse hair, and the brush helps groom the hair and distribute the pigment all across. It is a great choice for creating naturally thick eyebrows on budget.
Maybelline New York Brow Pencil
Every woman knows that the perfect brow look is the ultimate combination of subtle definition and relentless blending. If you are someone who understands this brow science as well as we do, the Maybelline New York Define and Blend Brow Pencil is the one for you. The unique angled tip allows you to create natural strokes, while the spoolie ensures that your arch looks smooth and subtle. The buildable formula allows you to opt for any look, from bold and glam to simple and sweet.
Prominent Features of the Maybelline New York Brow Pencil:
- Good colour pay-off
- Creamy formula
- Heat-proof and waterproof
- Offers high coverage
- Easy to draw
- No sharpening needed
- Buildable coverage
- Very limited product quantity
In addition to this, we would also like you to check our latest blog, where we have mentioned some of the top brands of liquid eyeliners available online in India. Do check it out.
Colorbar Stunning Eyebrow Pencil
This Colorbar Stunning Eyebrow Pencil is smudge-proof and perfect for getting a sharp, well-highlighted edge. The long-lasting formula gives beautiful brows and does not flake off even after long, sweaty hours of wear. This brow pencil comes with a built-in brush that helps spread and set the brow hair.
Prominent Features of the Colorbar Stunning Eyebrow Pencil:
- Full coverage
- Contains natural antioxidants
- Good colour pay-off
- Oil-free formula
- Stays all day long
- Suitable for all skin types
- Available in a single shade
L’Oreal Paris Cosmetics Stylist Definer Brow Liner
L’Oreal Paris is one of the largest and top-notch cosmetic brands in India, selling the best of the best beauty products. This eyebrow pencil is one of them. It has a super-fine tip that helps draw tiny brow hairs and fill empty spots without a hassle. The other end of the pencil has a spoolie, perfect for blending and combing the brows to get a clean, well-defined shape.
Prominent Features of the L’Oreal Paris Cosmetics Stylist Definer Brow Liner:
- Mechanical and retractable pencil
- Comes with a soft spoolie brush
- Ophthalmologist Tested
- Precise tip for the perfect eyebrow
- Provides seamless finish
- Available in multiple shades
- It is easy to break with little pressure
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil
NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil is a top-quality eyebrow pencil and is ideal for sizing and shaping the brows the way you want. It is an elegant pencil with a super skinny tip and a grooming brush. It helps draw extra-fine lines easily and get beautiful eyebrows without professional help. This pencil is lightweight and easy to hold. While it is slightly more expensive than other brows products, it is worth every buck spent.
Prominent Features of the NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Micro Brow Pencil:
- Ultra skinny Micro Brow Pencil
- Smudge resistant
- Water and sweat-resistant
- Vegan Formula
- It goes well with all eyebrow types
- It has 8 shades
- Lasts all day long
- Slightly expensive
e.l.f. Essential Instant Lift Brow Pencil
This dual-sided eyebrow pencil by e.l.f is an excellent tool that helps shape, colour, and set brows in 2 easy steps. One side of the pencil features an ultra-slim liner, and another end has a spoolie for taming and combing the brows. Its ultra-thin tip helps create fine hairline strokes and gives a natural hue. This product is free from phthalates, parabens, etc., making it one of the best eyebrow pencils in India, even for contact lens wearers.
Prominent Features of the e.l.f. Ultra-Precise Brow Pencil:
- 100% cruelty-free and vegan
- Dual-sided design
- The creamy, smudge-proof formula
- It comes in multiple shades
- Ultra-fine tip
- It has good pigmentation
- It is not so waxy
Swiss Beauty Eyebrow Pencil
The Swiss Beauty Eyebrow Pencil is a waterproof and smudge-proof pencil with a smooth, pigmented formula. It glides over the eyebrows easily and is convenient for creating fuller arches that frame your face well. This pencil gives full coverage that lasts all day long. It also has a brush on the cap that gives a natural yet professional finish.
Prominent Features of the Swiss Beauty Eyebrow Pencil:
- Highly-pigmented pencil
- It blends well with all skin tones
- Smooth in application
- Low maintenance
- Easy to use
- Offers full-coverage
- Spoolie does not blend smoothly
L’Oreal and Wet n Wild pencils deliver expert-level brows without spending a lot of time and effort. However, all listed eyebrow pencils are great for anyone looking to transform their brow game. So, read all about them and pick the one that matches your requirements.
Which eyebrow pencil is best for beginners?
Wild n Wild Ultimate Brow Pencil is a great choice for beginners. It is lightweight and easy to hold, which reduces the chances of messing up the eyebrows.
Should eyebrow pencils be darker or lighter?
Picking the right colour eyebrow pencil is very important for a natural finish. You must always pick a colour that is a bit lighter than the actual brow colour because the oils in our skin oxidise the pigment and make it look darker.
Is pencil or powder better for eyebrows?
Eyebrow pencils work best for filling in the brows with precise strokes. Pencils mimic the natural hair and give a better finish. However, they are difficult to apply in a natural way and require a lot of practice. On the other hand, the powder is used for filling in the spaces of skin between the hair. While they are easy to apply, they won’t offer well-defined arches.
Why Trust CashKaro Reviews?
CashKaro has a team of highly-skilled, experienced researchers who thoroughly investigate various items before providing you with the best recommendations. They filter out the best products by considering multiple factors like formula, colour, finish, price, and even user feedback. Our motive is to provide you with the most trustworthy recommendations to help you make an informed decision.